2009年4月7日 星期二

Functional Grammar of English Group

組員: 林仲茂 王孝承 楊仲寧 陳祁繁 蕭宇君

◎探討動機

在學習英語的歷程中,不定詞及動名詞佔了相當大的篇幅,除了探討二者句法上的同異,更比較語意上的分別。而在所謂虛主詞 it 替代不定詞及動名詞在句法上的位置,而將語意主詞(即不定詞與動名詞)後移的句型中,組員們發現語意主詞後移之後,產生不定詞及動名詞的不平均分布,以 It + is …to V 型式出現的比例極高,相較之下,It is …Ving 的型式相當罕見。因此,為針對此現象有更進一步的了解,便試圖從坊間參考書籍與文法書中找尋合理的解釋,更經由搜尋語料庫,做初步的假設。

◎中學文法

在國中英文文法中,使用動名詞和不定詞做為主詞是相當的情況,從國二下學期便開始介紹動名詞和不定詞的各類用法。

而於該階段文法中,以動名詞和不定詞為句子主詞是相關文法中的前幾個。國中教師多年教導學生,做為主詞時不定詞等同動名詞,例:Learning English is fun. = To learn English is fun.。其後,便開始教導虛主詞 it為首,將不定詞或動名詞後移作為真主詞,例:To learn /Learning English is fun. = It is fun to learn English.。但就組上組員教學經驗分享,覺得學生有時常會困惑於何故原本均可作主詞之兩種詞類,移往句子後方便只能用 to V 而非 Ving? ( ?It is fun learning English.) 是以,無論國中教師或是補習班老師,每每將此句型公式化教學,將 It is 此一句型作為 trigger,看到此主詞開頭,動詞便立時使用不定詞。此為國中英語教學之一沉疴,是故欲深入探討之。

以下為擷取自坊間參考書籍及文法書中針對此句型之陳述:

()

It = Infinitive Phrase, Gerund Phrase, or Noun Clause

結構上的it可以代替不定詞片語、動名詞片語、以及名詞子句。it在下面的句子中不是真的主詞或真的受詞,真正的主詞與真正的受詞可能是不定詞片語、動名詞片語、或者名詞子句。何以用it來替代不定詞片語、動名詞片語、或者名詞子句呢?第一: 不定詞片語、動名詞片語、以及名詞子句觀念上是抽象的,所以可以it來替代。第二: 不定詞片語、動名詞片語、以及名詞子句都可以當主詞或受詞,但他們往往太過於長。﹝That John forgot the keyirritated Mary.這種句型文法上絕對正確,偶爾這麼寫無妨。但常常用不定詞片語、動名詞片語、或者名詞子句當主詞,讓人感覺頭重腳輕,而在英文裡不喜歡頭重腳輕的句子。簡單的說就是不要罹患大頭症。I thinkthat she finished her job all by herselfimpossible.這種句型的受詞太長,到造成我們理解的困難。把這個句子改成I think it impossible that she finished her job all by herself.則句意清楚易懂。這裡我們可以深深體會文句子的主詞與受詞太長都不是好現象,即使文法對了,仍然讓人讀起來辛苦。

From: 英文句法精義 句子的萬種風情Sentence Variety Through English Grammar P.190 書林出版有限公司 吳帆





2. 有時,會在不定詞之前加入形式上的主詞“for +某人”。

【注意】easy, difficult, fun,…+ for +人。但現在分詞 (-ing),interesting, exciting, boring, 以及important…要用“for+ 人”,或者“to+ 人”也可以。

3. 上述提到的句型有三個,它們是可以互通的。見下例:

Playing computer games is easy for me.

= To play computer games is easy for me.

=It’s easy for me to play computer games.

From: Go SuperTeens!4 朗文版 斷層掃描英語4 P.117 高昇出版社股份有限公司

(四)

It is +形容詞句型之辨別

1.句型1: It is +形容詞+ to+原形動詞…(做某事是 的)→表示說或者個人主觀認知

: It is difficult to study math. (學數學是困難的)

句型2: It is+ 形容詞+for ++to +原形動詞(對某人而言,做某事是的。)

→主詞是後面“to +原形動詞...,可省略for+ 某人。

: It is dangerous for us to swim in the ocean. (對我們而言,在海裡游泳是危險的。)

句型3: It is+ 形容詞+ of ++ to +原形動詞。→某人具有某特質而去做某事。

: It is kind of him to help me move the desk. (他很好心的幫我搬那張桌子。)

From: 雙向溝通複習講義 英語 98基本學測專用最新版 P.161 金安文教機構

◎語料庫

為了解此句型真實的使用情況,經由搜尋British National Corpus,以便閱讀真實語料。

由語料庫中可知,可用 It is…Ving之句型僅搜尋到 It is worthwhile Ving 以及 It is no use Ving之用法。但同時,在以上兩種用法中,使用to V的句型亦並存於英文中。(如附錄一中標※號者)是故,我們可以嗅出其中差異,即用to V Ving之差別為新舊訊息之陳述,例如:

AS0 787 If he cannot balance and control his movements, it is no use for him to try to practise `;walking'; with the help of therapists or nurses.

A3T 169 It is no use wringing hands and regretting this preference.

正如不定詞和動名詞之用法,動名詞予人舊訊息(即發生過之經驗)之感,不定詞則傳達新訊息(亦即將發生或尚未做),是故中文經常將 to V翻成「去」,以表達未來感。

遺憾的是,我們並無法由語料庫中,除了It is worthwhile Ving 以及 It is no use Ving用法之外,找到其餘的形容詞同時擁有to V / Ving之用法。/ Ving之用法。

是故,我們並無法再就此一問題做出更深入之探究,是否因大部分形容詞均通用於新訊息之表述?這仍是我們存疑之處。

Dear all,

你們在這裡提出的問題似乎牽涉了太多的variables以致於模糊了問題的焦點。你們至少提到了以下諸點:

(1) to V vs. V-ing 的不同

(2) It …to V / V-ing / that有何不同

(3) …V it … to V…

也因為問題有些模糊,所以很難聚焦去深入找語料比對分析。

建議先把問題定錨之後,再重新省視。

資料來源:

    1. 英文句法精義 句子的萬種風情Sentence Variety Through English Grammar P.190 書林出版有限公司 吳帆

2. Azar 英文文法系列(進階)第三版 Understanding And Using English Grammar P.323 敦煌書局 Betty Schrampfer Azar

3. Go SuperTeens!4 朗文版 斷層掃描英語4 P.117 高昇出版社股份有限公司

4. 雙向溝通複習講義 英語 98基本學測專用最新版 P.161 金安文教機構

5. British National Corpus

(附錄一)

以下為語料庫中所得之結果:

It is…to…

CDR 1057 If you really do love your pasta, it is probably best to allow yourself to indulge in a sensible pasta for your main course.

ABG 155 Euro-visionaries claim it is possible to strengthen European defence co-operation in collaboration with America, not in competition with it.

AJX 257 Easing inflation is proving to be a painfully slow process and yesterday's small fall must make any thinking Chancellor wonder whether it is safe to cut interest rates further.

BNV 666 It is my intention to foster the formation of a body of people interested in aerobatics in Scotland, both pilots and non-pilots, with the purpose of increasing the awareness of aerobatics here and of promoting instruction and participation in the sport.

ADF 218 In general, it is best to geld a colt before he is one-year old.

CGF 407 It is interesting to look at how the more extreme case is explained.

AS0 787 If he cannot balance and control his movements, it is no use for him to try to practise `;walking'; with the help of therapists or nurses.

A6A 40 It is worthwhile to choose a rehearsal room which suits your music, and stick to it.

A6A 2395 It is worthwhile for the band to keep some diary notes as to the studios they have used and on which days.

C9B 972 Winch's criticism of this way of looking at morality, as we have shown, is that it separates the person who acts from the world in which he acts, and a man has to be shown that it is worthwhile for him to act morally.

CM6 255 But it is worthwhile to reiterate that, in a sense, every book published about recent history is of value as a source and the conventional `;official'; documentation does not necessarily occupy in recent history the commanding place which its comparative isolation in a sea of illiteracy gives it in earlier epochs.

CRX 256 Indeed, it is an oddity that he seemed to see the criminal justice system as being the only aspect of the environment that influences individual decisions about whether it is worthwhile to commit crime or not.

EW9 1261 It is worthwhile to anticipate events a little and quote at length from the Governors' Statement of that same month:

H0E 2043 The question is whether it is worthwhile to check out the" priorities even when we seem to have what we want.

H0U 1054 It is worthwhile to consider some models of polymer structure and ascertain their usefulness as representative volume elements (RVE).

HU2 4974 It is worthwhile to recall that the specificity of the viral attack seems to be another important variable, as ANA-H and SMA-AA are exceedingly rare in chronic liver disease induced by hepatitis B virus, while a peculiar autoantibody profile has been reported in hepatitis D virus chronic liver disease.

A0H 326 Clearly, it is important to consider each of the ways in which you can safeguard your equipment because it is no use avoiding all the flying hazards if you are going to write off your glider on the ground.

ALW 766 He acknowledged that it is essential to maintain the balance between basic research and commissioned research.

C9W 840 It is better by far for the patient to have a week or so in which to mull over all that has occurred and everything he or she has learnt about the past.

EV4 160 In describing reading as an information-processing skill it is necessary to identify the sources of information and the cognitive processes applied to that information, and to indicate how these sources and processes vary as the skill develops.

EVX 628 What it is in general for a thing a to have the power to produce b is for it to be true that an individual property or properties of a, together with other things, will constitute a causal circumstance for b.

F9B 410 It is difficult to see how unrepresented claimants who fare so badly in tribunals of first instance could expect to fare better at the appellate level; indeed representation has increased considerably over the past few years.

G2G 597 It is hoped also to include a demonstration of the Directory of Cognitive Science/HCI Community.

H7R 124 It is difficult to manufacture a small permanent.magnet rotor with a large number of poles and consequently stepping motors of this type are restricted to step lengths in the range 30-;90 degrees.

J2K 534 It is essential to distinguish different kinds of usage of deictic expression.

B33 921 It is reasonably accurate to say that good teaching comes largely from thorough planning, yet all too often far too little planning time is made available.

C9J 2424 As a piece this was undoubtedly a composed solo, and although on the record quite a few of the phrases were `;dropped in';, it is obviously possible to play through it in one pass.

CG1 447 It is not advisable to attempt this walk in conditions of poor visibility since the plateau is featureless and it's difficult to know when you are close to the Ben Crom crags.

HPU 1242 However, it is necessary to note that there is a limit to the number of variables that can be held constant in this way.

AKE 1691 It is better to do one or two and then opt for more sensible distances.

APR 746 It is believed to be Miss Glover who first encouraged Christabel to embark on the grandiose and obscure epic poem, The Fairy Melusina , a retelling of the old tale of the magical half-woman, half-snake

B76 412 It is now much easier to travel in these areas, but collecting wild cocoa and other species of the rainforest has suddenly become very urgent.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It is…Ving

CEK 5915 IT IS no use putting all the blame on young drivers for the high number of accidents.

A0W 31 It is no use stimulating muscle growth if your protein intake is insufficient.

A2P 219 It is no use us trying to clobber the economy with high taxation any more than it's any use Lawson clobbering the economy with high interest rates…

A3T 169 It is no use wringing hands and regretting this preference.

AE7 890 But again, it is no use just burning sugars: that would merely make things hot.

A65 752 Most visitors to this region concentrate on the coast but it is worthwhile heading inland where a large network of lanes provides some quiet cycling.

A6A 1691 But, as always, it is worthwhile finding out more about your local station.

AML 631 Nevertheless, it is worthwhile attempting to relate the NVC to what is known about the vegetation.

APC 1185 (It is worthwhile here remembering the jaguar's requirements.)

APX 63 Despite this cloud that appears to be looming over the industry, it is worthwhile bearing in mind that the impact of interest rates and the poll tax is not felt uniformly across the country or among different groups.

AT6 254 Although to start with you can use ordinary sports shoes, in the long term it is worthwhile investing in some purpose-designed windsurfing footwear.

AT6 686 The local sailors are the people who probably know the conditions best, so it is worthwhile speaking to someone who can point out the idiosyncrasies of the location.

B1M 721 In the meantime it is worthwhile continuing to take newspapers and magazines to the paper banks which are close to us.

B1M 811 So it is worthwhile finding cleaning materials that are phosphate free.

C91 575 Special low-current l.e.d. 's are available from several suppliers and it is worthwhile using them.

C92 1220 However, there are some commonly used components where it is worthwhile having two or three of each in stock, and this is my list of suggested buys.

CBC 7646 Virtually anything is possible here and, for a relaxing change of pace, it is worthwhile hunting out a slow boat instead of sticking to a frenetic dash in the fast lane.

CJE 88 It is worthwhile arranging a veterinary check at an early stage, to ensure that your new companion is in good health.

CN2 356 It is worthwhile taking a moment to look at regulation 4 because it governs the whole attitude of the AlB towards its responsibilities.

FTW 1220 It is worthwhile briefly examining Lukacs's ideas on socialist realism at this juncture since they not only provide a constructive critical alternative to the mindless ideological stance adopted by Zhdanov, Radek and Stetsky, but also broaden the global conceptual framework within which to examine Nizan's communist novels.

G0R 963 That being so, it is worthwhile recalling the view of the student that went with that earlier epistemology and which generated the idea of students' academic freedom (or Lernfreiheit , as it was known).

G37 1896 It is worthwhile practising timed starts to get a feel for how fast your yacht accelerates and slows down, and how long it takes to cover a certain distance.

GU6 112 Since such divisions held sway prior to Ridge, and have on occasion reappeared, it is worthwhile examining the value of such criteria.

GWK 502 It is worthwhile looking at the advantages and disadvantages of copyright at a time when it has achieved worldwide acceptability.

H0J 306 If you own a computer it is worthwhile entering all your vocabulary on to a disk from early on in your programme.

H9M 877 It is worthwhile restating here what those results are.

HAC 2100 At least once a year it is worthwhile taking a look inside your machine.

HB6 715 When dealing with a claim for freezer contents it is worthwhile considering the capacity of the freezer in relation to the size of the claim.

HWF 1133 It is worthwhile carrying out QA on packages before major review points such as a critical design review.

HWF 14044 LIFESPAN will perform this check during the approval process, but it is worthwhile knowing that it can also be performed by the user, thus avoiding any inconvenience to himself or the approver.

HXD 1076 Bearing this in mind (and the same applies to the unregistered design right generally and to copyright works) it is worthwhile keeping good records of the development of the topography so that the date it was created can be proved in a court of law.

J1E 67 It is worthwhile noting that Liverpool have spent a colossal amount rebuilding Anfield in addition to their outlay on linguistically-challenged scandinavian defenders.

J2L 1384 It is worthwhile recalling here that the great pavement at Woodchester is the largest domestic mosaic north of the Alps.

K90 567 It is worthwhile recognising that in the attenuation bands of the purely reactive ladder filters considered, the characteristic impedances are pure reactances because .

沒有留言:

##EasyReadMore##